onno van braam
computer graphics, webdevelopment

Summary

Modeling car rims is actually fairly easy and straightforward. This is because there always is some sort of symmetry, always. Whether it be point-, line- or suface-symmetry, there's always one or a combination. This will reduce modeling difficulty and effort tremendously, since Max has, since version 5, the Symmetry modifier which is very handy.

The Rim and Symmetry Analysis

Well before jumping in I think we should first pick a rim which we'll try and recreate.

After browsing to one of my favorite rim makers, Toora, I picked one out which is as good an example as any:

Do realize we will probably not be making all those nuts and bolts, maybe if I have some time at the end.
Anyways: as you can see, there is a five-fold symmetry here. 5 Center nuts and 5 arms. So what we are going to do is modeling one arm, one nut hole, one bolt / nut and 1/5th of the outer rim and that's it. Nothing more. No way that I am going model the whole thing. We are going to let the Symmetry modifier do all the work for us.

Okay I've drawn some of the symmetry options that are available in the next image:

Immediately after I drew this, I realized: there's not only a 5 fold symmetry (the red and green part), but even a 10-fold one (the blue part)! So all we have to do is model a part of 36 degrees (360 for a total circle, divided by 10) and symmetry it so that it makes up the entire rim. I have been very lucky choosing this one as you can see... Would this rim have 5 arms and 6 nut holes then it would be way, way, way more work, it's then when you start cursing Max and wished you used Rhino. But that is not the case and it hardly is, as said, there is almost symmetry on every rim.

Start: Outline and Basic Shape

I talk a lot about basic shapes with which I mean that I always model something that roughly looks the way I want it to look and then start detailing and refining. I see many modelers work in a different way and that is cool, but I feel that my method is especially good when you want to learn and also works well for finding errors or misformed parts of your model more easily.

So first a rough outline which we will use as guidance. In the front view I create Circle with a radius of 100 (1)(remember that in 3D modeling everything is about relative sizes, not absolute sizes, so 100 is absolutely arbitrary, but handy to work with) and a cilinder with radius 100, both at position 0, 0, 0 (2). In the Cilinder set the height to something like -30, height segments 1, sides 20.

Now for a bit of math. I said that we will only model one part of 36 degrees. So click the 'Slice On' radio button of the cilinder. In math the 0 degrees line is at the middle right (1). So for example slicing from 0 to 90 gives result (2). We want a total of 36 degrees and I want it at the center top. So we slice from 90 + 36/2 = 108 to 90-36/2 = 72 degrees and hooray, it works as expected (3). Hm, but now that I think of it: having it at the center top isn't handy, because what we will be modeling is only half an arm of the rim which I want at the center top at the end. So we shift the slicing 18 degrees. Slice from 90 to 54 (4) This may look like nonsense, but it'll become clear very soon.

Let's have a test run at how the symmetry modifier will help us out. Add one (1), and if everything is correct it should be at the right place and angle already. Add another one (it will be at the same position and angle as the first one) and rotate it (in the sub-object of the modifier, yes modifiers also have an SO, usually for editting their Gizmo's) 36 degrees. This is best done by clicking the 'Absolute Mode Transform Type In' which then becomes 'Offset Mode Transform Type In' button at the bottom center of your screen. This button changes the amount you give the rotate / move / scale from absolute to relative. When you set it to Offset, it adds it (the amount you want) to the current value, which is what we want now. This way you save yourself calculation time. :) So fill in 36 in the Z-direction (rotate!!, not move) (3). As you can see we are not yet at 10 parts, so add another one, rotate this one 72 degrees (twice the 36 of last time) (4). Now comes a part where you might think it'll go wrong: we are going to add another Symmetry modifier. This will result in 16 parts in total, while we only wanted 10. But the modifier has a Threshold, so it will symmetry it over the ones you created in the first couple modifiers and weld them away. They won't be seen. So add, rotate 144 degrees (5). In the last part of the next image I show how your modifier list should look right now (6) And also the Transform Type-In thingie.

So far for the boring part, now it's time to take advantage of what we just created.

Copy the original circle and give it a radius of about 35 (1). This will work as a guidance when we model the center part. Then copy it again, set the radius to 10, move it to make the guidance for the nut holes (2). Now I drew a line (with Initial Type 'Smooth' and Drag Type 'Smooth') to help as guidance when modeling the arm (3).

Modeling

All outlines are set, so we can now start modeling. Back to the original cilinder, click the 'Show End Result On/Off Toggle' so that you only see the single part (1). Set the Sides to 3 and Cap Segments to 3 (2).

Now we want to have an EP (we want to model!!), but we have a cilinder, that's tricky since we have all those modifiers and don't have the option 'Convert to Editable Poly' without collapsing the modifiers along with it. But Max is to the rescue, it has a nice copy/paste function for modifiers. So select all the symmetry modifiers by Ctrl clicking them and then right click, Cut. You modifiers are now cut and placed in memory just as it would work with text. Then convert your cilinder to an EDITABLE MESH (!!) and then to an EP (somehow Max fucks up if you convert directly to an EP), right click it in the modifier panel (where you just clicked Cut) and click Paste.

Before we go into the VSO, go to the PSO and delete the sides of your sliced cilinder (3 + 4), they will give troubles when using the symmetry modifier, and the rear part too (5). So now we have a total flat part of the original cilinder. Into the Vertex Sub-Object we go now, we want to shape it (6)!

So modeling now, but first set the interpolation of all circles created to 'Adaptive', this way they're perfectly smooth and better guidance.

In the VSO start moving the vertices around so that match all your guidance lines (1) and delete what you don't need (2). Click the 'Toggle End Result' button to see whether we are getting somewhere (3). I think we are! This is starting to look like something and all with very little effort. You could work with the TER button On all the time, this is a very good way to see the result of what you're doing immediately and all over the whole rim (especially with an MS modifier of course).

So do a little editting of vertices and slicing to make it fit better (1 + 2) and we're done for the moment. What we have now is an almost perfect 2D representation of what we want in the end. From now on things will go faster: you have the knowledge know of how to setup the symmetry and then all you have to do is model one bit perfectly and you're set. I changed the shape of the outlines since I noticed the rim was getting too fat compared to the original, editted some more vertices (2).

The next thing we will do is make the nut hole. Go to the PSO and slice the shape so that it matches your guiding circle (1). Cut some additional lines to prevent errors later on (2) (keep your mesh tidy!). Select the polygons that make up the hole and extrude inwards (3), delete the polygon in the middle that you just created, you don't want that, once again because of the symmetry modifier.

Now in the ESO select some edges that make up the side of the arm (1), to give it thickness, by shift-dragging them (2), and the end result should look someting like this (3):

All to do now is chamfering edges to define the shape better and 3D the whole lot to make it more look like the original. I am not going through all those steps it would be a repitition of previous tutorials and also a lead-by-the-hand type of tutorial which I don't like. Tutorials should be about concepts not step by step explanations. This is what I got after 5 minutes of editting and chamfering etc.:

Either you call it a day here, or you make one final addition: the outer rim cilinder. This you could make separate from the part we just made or make it a whole. We'll try the latter.

I didn't change much at the top end of the arm and so you shouldn't have too much trouble folliwing the next steps. Create a tube with radius 100 and 103, same slice as before (90, 54) or at least make it fit the rim (1) and then delete all polies except for the inner ones to be left with a small strip (2) then delete the last polygon (3), attach the rim to this tube part and weld some vertices to make it form a whole, then select some edges and shift-drag them (4 + 5).

Some more chamfering and shift-dragging where need and you should be all set. Then you should (or could :P) have something like this (1) and I can think you can do the rest yourself now! It may not resemble the original perfectly, but you only have to change one single part...

And here an example of a little more worked out rim, with a semi-nice texture.


Comments

Kacper
2009/08/07
I would like to do a 1/5th but symetry doesnt work righ like that.when I add last one it messes up.PLEASE HELP!
ASHSIH
2009/06/29
I AM JUST A STUDENT OF CLASS NINTH AND COMPLETELY NEW TO 3D. THANKS A LOT ,WITH YOUR HELP I WAS ABLE TO MAKE MY FIRST 3D MADEL.GOD BLESS YOU.
Noman Hassan
2008/12/21
nice technique
akash dalal
2008/12/11
Hi, my prob solve thanks, god bles u
Raj
2008/06/17
It's too cool.I really liked.Thanks:-)
Olly
2008/06/16
I give up. Bad tutorial for beginners. Nothing works as it should do. The symmetry thing is just insane. I think you need a degree from MIT to be able to carry this out properly. If someone can email me with instructions on how this is supposed to work, please do. I am about to put my fist through the monitor!
Olly
2008/06/16
I'm a bit lost here. When I select the 'symmetry' modifier for my cylinder, it just disappears! It doesn't do what your tutorial indicates that it should do.
Stuntman Mike
2008/01/17
Problem solved. It was about the order of the Symmetries and the MeshSmooth, it was only affecting the cylinder.
Stuntman Mike
2008/01/16
Hi. First of all let me say, YOU RULE.

So, i'm stuck almost at the end of the tut. When i MS the rim after, chamfering and all the center creates a hole, kind of star shape, i've tried to chamfer the center vertex, and messed arround with the symmetreasieary threshold but the result is allways bad. lol.

I'm gonna keep trying but with a little explanation of what might be wrong would be a lot more easier :). Sorry for bothering.
Radel
2007/07/11
In the name of all of us who want to learn 3D Modeling and can´t afford an art school, Thank you very much!!!!!

I have been looking for these tutorials for a long time, since I was having such a hard time with 3D Max Help File.

ali reza bayat
2007/03/01
You perform this project very easy and good.

goodluck
juan carlos
2007/02/08
del putas man
DJ WeB
2007/01/22
Nice job dude... Clean work...
shb
2007/01/21
again thanks that is some way
off
2007/01/17
oh ! god It's reality ... Thank for your teach...
Sharvil
2006/12/15
hey nice tutorial but how did you end up finishing up because i don't know where and how to chamfer the edges to make it look like that. And also how did you bend it instead of it being flat.
jbgdream
2006/12/14
Hello,

I am following your tuto about Poly Modeling and arrived hardly but successfully (I'm a real beginner!) to this part, about the rim. You wrote above:

"Copy the original circle and give it a radius of about 35 (1). This will work as a guidance when we model the center part. Then copy it again, set the radius to 10, move it to make the guidance for the nut holes (2). Now I drew a line (with Initial Type 'Smooth' and Drag Type 'Smooth') to help as guidance when modeling the arm (3)."

How can I be abble to see the Line (3) when I draw it? I don't see those ten blue divisions anymore then( even when I do (1) and (2) ). It seams that the Cylinder hides the drawing. So it wasn't so easy to place (2) well. Is it used as a background? Are they grouped or something like that?

Would you help me to work with those outlines (and go further on this tuto)?!! If you have some of your precious time to spend (lose?)... I would be very gratefull.

If you haven't that time, well, thanks allready for all what you have shared, that I've understood and managed to follow, learn and practice for a part.

Votre obligé, Jean-Benoit ( Britanny, France).

Admin Edit: The 10 division lines come from the cilinder, right? And the lines and circles I was drawing in those three images are references/guidances lines, new lines; they're separate objects. You should definately be able to see those 10 division lines. When you're in the wireframe view (as in the screenshots) then you should be able to see all the objects, unless there is a problem with 2-sided-ness (polygons have normals and when 2-sided is not turned on in your viewport, you won't see them when looking from behind).

J'espere que je t'aide un peu avec cette instructions. ;)

Sorry for my bad french, but I trully hope my explanation helps a bit. If not, don't hesitate to drop me an e-mail, or a comment here.
dimitar
2006/12/11
weri good
kashif
2006/12/01
Can you send me this tutorial to my e-mail plz
miguel mela
2006/11/20
Can you send me this tutorial to my e-mail plz

Admin Edit: Nope.
Sanghvi Neha
2006/11/20
plz give me information how can we make a modling of 3d car i.e. the whole structure.
thanks
Chrisfasipebi
2006/11/05
I can't believe my eyes, this is amazing
Thanks...like I'm in a school and very quick to learn
Just keep up the good work guys, am luvin it. YEAH!
Tim
2006/10/31
i got lost.. where is "Slice On" box..?
lero
2006/08/27
it's 3ds max
Dr. Zoidberg
2006/08/23
To Rune:
I experienced the same problem, but this is the trick:
you have to do the rotations in the "mirror" sub-object level of the symmetry modifiers.
CMVIJAI
2006/08/11
This is amazing.......... GET LOST
LT Guy
2006/08/03
it´s cool shit
BoPeter
2006/07/25
This is amazing. These techniques are so ease and brillinant, that it's unbelievable!!!! THANKS!!!
bharat
2006/07/11
you are a genius of max ,pal....
wil_c
2006/07/09
an easy step by step tutorial. even an beginer could follow. now trying to make more variants of the rim. thanx a million~!~!~
Xses
2006/06/20
Its 3ds Max the prog he used i was wondering if there is anything better than 3ds max 8
Bart
2006/06/17
What program u used?
it looks great..
and i wanna try it too.
zahi zgheib
2006/04/05
could we do the design of the rim on AUTOCAD.
what program are you using.
thanks
Rune
2006/03/22
Hi. When i use the slice modifier, the previous "slice" disappeares. It looks like that when i add the next slice modifier it just moves the outline (part) rather than adding a new one. Wonder what i do wrong?? Perhaps i use the wrong command when i add the modifier? I just click "symmetry" in the sub cathegory in the cylinder modifier list. I use 3DS Max 8.
admyn3D
2006/03/07
Respect man, I work in Blender, OS FreeBSD 6.0 RELEASE, but this tutorial help me to make this very good rims!
MARTS[FRENCH]
2006/02/26
Very nice !!!thank you for tutorial ;)
Gourang
2006/02/18
this a very good tutorial